The History of Italian Wine Investing

Plus: an exclusive at-home dining offer for WineFi customers.

The Italian Syndicate

This week we’ll be continuing along the theme of our latest investment opportunity, The Italian Syndicate, and diving into the history of fine wine in the two regions in focus - Tuscany and Piedmont.

The Italian Syndicate gives investors access to an expertly-curated portfolio of investment-grade wines from Italy’s two premier wine regions – Tuscany and Piedmont – at a fraction of the cost of owning the total portfolio outright.

Returns are exempt from Capital Gains Tax (CGT) for UK investors, and you can gain exposure from just £3,000. Fees are equivalent to just 2% per year.

Due to record interest in this syndicate, we will be opening a second tranche to allow additional investors the chance to access this exciting opportunity.

Click here to view The Italian Syndicate investment thesis

Introduction

Italy consistently ranks among the world's top three wine-producing countries, with viticulture dating back to the 8th century BCE. While Italian wine has a long history, its fine wine market, particularly in Tuscany, has developed significantly since the 1980s, driven by established wine-making families including Antinori, Rocchetta, and Frescobaldi.

Tuscany

The Rise of the Super Tuscan

The story of modern Tuscan wine begins with an act of rebellion. In the late 1960s, Piero Antinori grew increasingly frustrated with the rigid DOC regulations that governed Chianti production. These rules, created in 1966, required the inclusion of white grapes in Chianti's blend and prohibited the use of international varieties. Meanwhile, his cousin Lodovico Antinori had witnessed the success of Bordeaux's wine-making methods during his time in France.

The Antinoris weren't alone in their discontent. In the hills of Bolgheri, far from Chianti's traditional heartland, Mario Incisa della Rocchetta had been quietly experimenting with Cabernet Sauvignon since the 1940s on his Tenuta San Guido estate. His private wine, Sassicaia (meaning "stony ground"), was about to change Italian wine history.

Global Recognition

In 1971, Piero Antinori made a decisive break with tradition. Working with winemaker Giacomo Tachis, he created Tignanello, a wine that deliberately flouted DOC rules by eliminating white grapes and incorporating Cabernet Sauvignon with Sangiovese. Due to its unorthodox composition, it was classified as a mere "table wine" - Italy's lowest designation.

The moment of vindication came in 1978 when Sassicaia, still classified as a humble table wine, outperformed several prestigious Bordeaux wines in a blind tasting. This event sent shockwaves through the wine establishment. Shortly after, Robert Parker awarded the 1985 Sassicaia a perfect 100-point score - the first Italian wine to achieve this distinction.

Regulatory Recognition

The success of these producers inspired others. Lodovico Antinori established Ornellaia in 1981, directly competing with his cousin's Tignanello and neighboring Sassicaia. The wine press coined the term "Super Tuscans" to describe these extraordinary table wines that commanded higher prices than many established DOC wines.

These developments led to changes in Italian wine classification. By the 1990s, the Toscana IGT (Indicazione Geografica Tipica) designation was established. Wines such as Tignanello, Sassicaia, and Ornellaia have since gained international recognition.

Piedmont

Foot of the Mountain

Piedmont's wine story is deeply connected to its landscape. Nestled in northwestern Italy, the region's name "Piemonte" – meaning "foot of the mountain" – reflects its geographical position at the base of the Alps. This location creates a unique climate: the mountains protect the vineyards from harsh northern weather, while maritime influences from the Ligurian Sea contribute to favourable growing conditions.

The Barolo Wars

The "Barolo Wars" of the 1980s embodied a dramatic generational clash over the identity of Piedmont's most prestigious wine. The dispute centred on Nebbiolo's challenging natural characteristics - its fierce combination of high acidity and robust tannins. Traditionalists, led by Giovanni Conterno and Mascarello, championed methods passed down through generations: extended macerations of up to 30 days and aging in massive Slavonian oak casks, arguing this was the only way to reveal Barolo's true character. These producers lived by the philosophy that great Barolo demanded patience, requiring decades of aging to achieve harmony.

The modernist rebellion was ignited by a younger generation of winemakers, most notably Elio Altare and Angelo Gaja, who challenged this rigid orthodoxy. Altare's dramatic act of taking a chainsaw to his father's traditional botti (large casks) symbolised the movement's revolutionary spirit. The modernists introduced French barriques, temperature-controlled fermentation, and shorter maceration times. As Altare famously declared, "I'm not interested in making great Barolo. I simply want to make great wine. And all the world's great red wines are matured in barriques."

Burgundy Parallels

The 1990s marked Piedmont’s emergence on the global stage. Critics and collectors began to recognise these wines’ aging potential and investment value. The parallel with Burgundy is particularly apt:

• Both regions focus on single varieties that clearly express terroir

• Both have a complex patchwork of single vineyards

• Both maintain a strong tradition of family ownership

• Both produce wines that combine power with elegance

Today, Piedmont’s trajectory suggests similar potential for value appreciation as seen in Burgundy’s development, particularly for single-vineyard wines from established producers.

The Italian Syndicate

Our newest investment opportunity consists of wines from Tuscany and Piedmont - to view the docs please follow the link below.

Click here to view The Italian Syndicate investment thesis

yhangry - Exclusive offer for WineFi Customers

We are constantly on the lookout for perks to offer WineFi investors.

With that in mind, we’re delighted to announce that we have partnered with yhangry to offer WineFi investors access to a private chef at the same cost as a restaurant.

From casual dining, Masterchefs on TV to Michelin dining — let yhangry take care of your Christmas get togethers.

Enjoy £60 on us using this link!